Often Imitated. Never Duplicated.

For generations, Pudgie's Pizza has been serving the Ithaca community with fresh, made-to-order pizza that's become a local favorite. Located at 215 Elmira Road, we're proud to be the neighborhood pizza shop families, students, businesses, and visitors count on for great food and friendly service.

Our goal has always been simple: serve delicious food, provide outstanding customer service, and make every guest feel like family.

Every pizza is prepared fresh using quality ingredients, whether you're ordering a classic cheese pizza or creating your own combination of toppings. Along with our signature pizzas, we offer wings, subs, salads, appetizers, calzones, desserts, and family meal deals that make feeding a crowd easy.

At Pudgie's, we believe great pizza starts with fresh ingredients and careful preparation. Every order is made with attention to quality, so you receive food that's hot, fresh, and made just the way you like it.

Whether you're grabbing lunch, picking up dinner for the family, or ordering for a party or game day, we're committed to delivering the same quality and consistency every time.

Being part of the Ithaca community means everything to us. We're grateful for the support of our loyal customers who have made us a trusted local pizza destination. From college students to longtime residents, we're proud to serve everyone who walks through our doors.

See you soon!

- Vinny